The FBI's Approach to Strategic Questioning: A Guide for Everyday Scenarios
In the realm of intelligence and law enforcement, one of the most critical skills an operative can master is effective questioning.
The Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI) has honed an array of strategic questioning techniques for years, which have proven instrumental in extracting truth during interrogations.
Interestingly, the principles behind these techniques are not limited to criminal investigations. They can be adapted for use in various everyday scenarios, ranging from business negotiations to resolving personal conflicts.
This intel serves as a guide to understanding and implementing these techniques, with the objective of turning them into invaluable tools in your tradecraft skillset.
Baseline Behavior Assessment
Before initiating any line of questioning, establish a baseline behavior for the individual. In intelligence work, this is crucial for identifying deviations that could signal deception. In layman's terms, get a read on how the person usually behaves when they are comfortable and telling the truth. Look for things like tone of voice, rate of speech, body language, and eye contact.
Tip: Always remember that people are unique, and cultural or individual factors can affect the baseline.
Types of Questions
Open-Ended Questions
These types of questions require more than a 'yes' or 'no' answer, encouraging the subject to speak freely. In a covert operation, open-ended questions can help you glean more information than anticipated.
Example: “What can you tell me about the project you're currently working on?" as opposed to "Are you working on a new project?"
Closed-Ended Questions
These are useful when you require specific information. In tactical scenarios, closed-ended questions can rapidly ascertain the status of a mission-critical component.
Example: "Is the perimeter secure?" as opposed to "Tell me about the perimeter."
Leading Questions
Use these cautiously. While leading questions can confirm your suspicions, they also guide the subject towards a particular answer, which could be counterproductive.
Example: "You were dissatisfied with the decision, weren't you?"
Mirroring
An advanced technique borrowed from the field of psychology, mirroring involves mimicking the other person's behavior subtly to build rapport. This is not about overt imitation; instead, mirror their body language, vocal tone, or word choices to create a sense of mutual understanding. This is often used in asset recruitment phases in covert operations.
Emotional Labeling
Attach a verbal label to the subject’s likely emotional state to show understanding and provoke further discussion. Saying something like, “You seem a bit anxious about discussing this topic,” will make them either confirm or deny your observation, thereby revealing more about their emotional state.
Accusation Audit
In a high-stakes situation, especially one where the subject may be defensive, consider using an "Accusation Audit." This technique involves preemptively acknowledging the accusations or negative feelings the subject likely holds against you to remove their sting and encourage honest dialogue. For instance, if in a clandestine operation, you are dealing with a hostile source, an accusation audit would sound like, "I know you have no reason to trust me, given that we're on opposite sides."
Keep reading with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to The Tradecraft Guide to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.